Town Board OKs AvalonBay Zoning; 1 Man Arrested

Despite rejection by school board and pleas to stop apartment project, Huntington Town Board approves zoning change to clear the way for planning to begin.

The approved zoning for the proposed Huntington Station AvalonBay project by a 4-1 vote Monday — but not without a fight from some opposed to the plan.

Raucous from the start, the regular town hall meeting reached a boiling point just before voting regarding a zoning change which cleared the way for the planning and construction of 379 AvalonBay housing units in Huntington Station. 

Laboring to maintain order from the large, vocal crowd throughout the meeting, Town Supervisor Frank Petrone ordered security to escort Anthony Caruso, 60, from a front row seat at about 10 p.m. for disrupting proceedings as board members gave final opinions regarding the AvalonBay project.

Throughout the meeting, Petrone called for order and warned Caruso several times after being interrupted.

But the warnings eventually gave way to mayhem.

"You destroy everything!" yelled Caruso to Petrone as the board supervisor spoke regarding his AvalonBay zoning vote. After the outbursts continued from Caruso, Petrone signaled for security as a room full of stunned residents looked on, some gasped in dismay.

In a loud scuffle, Caruso was physically removed from the meeting by Suffolk County police and charged with 2nd degree harassment and disorderly conduct before being released on bail for arraignment at a future date, according to police.

Petrone said he was "a little disappointed" with some of the displays at the meeting, but "proud" of others who carried themselves as professionals.

"All of us have to be civil whether we agree with something or not," said Petrone.

A previous AvalonBay plan met considerable opposition from some in the Huntington Station community and was rejected by the Town Board in September. In March, the builders submitted a new, scaled-down proposal for review.

Despite what she said were "uncertainties" with the new plan on Monday, board member Susan Berland voted in favor of the revised AvalonBay project.

"It will bring immediate benefits and serve as a catalyst for even greater improvements and growth," said Berland. "The proposal now before us, if not perfect, is better."

At a meeting at Jack Abrams Intermediate School in Huntington Station earlier in the evening, the Huntington School Board voted unanimously against the AvalonBay project in a "posture of nonsupport based on financial impact.” 

"We've been completely thrown under the bus again," said school board trustee Kim Brown, regarding the AvalonBay proposal.

Before construction begins, AvalonBay must go through the entire planning process, said Petrone, after the vote. Monday's vote "means the zone has changed and they can proceed."

In a written statement, AvalonBay's representatives said they were grateful to their supporters and pleased with the vote.

"We recognize that we have our work cut out for us, but we are confident that, in the end, this development will help to bring the community together and result in a better Huntington for all residents,"  said Matt Whalen, AvalonBay's vice president for development.

Town Board member Mark Mayoka cast the lone vote against the AvalonBay plan.

The Suffolk County Planning Commission cleared the way for the town board's vote Monday by unanimously approving the zoning change last week in Riverhead. 

Marita Eybergen June 09, 2011 at 01:00 PM
@Kim, I beg to differ, I have seen people come and go in all the illegal housing in my area alone. I have one house on my block that has 13 bedrooms which the town discovered when the homeowner wanted to make their home legal which should be at most a 3 bedroom house. Yes some people are having children, but I bet if they did a study on the H/S area only (between Broadway and Pulaski & Pulaski to the school line which I think is 10th Ave) that is where the increase was. This is what happens when you have absentee landlords, they rent every part of the house. They will turn every room into a bedroom that is what PIUS also does. So a two bedroom house now becomes 5 bedrooms and for some reason Section 8 accepts that too. Not to mention extra cars, because that same house with the 13 bedrooms has at least 5 to 6 cars which they happen to park on the front lawn and in the street since they do not have enough parking space in their driveway. So we need to go back to going after all the illegal housing which turn every room into a bedroom.
Kyle June 09, 2011 at 02:34 PM
I resent you calling a 60 year old man elderly. He might be AARP eligible but 60 is certainly not elderly.
Angelo Garcia III June 09, 2011 at 03:35 PM
As a resident, I applaud the members of the Town Board to have the courage to vote for this project that is needed to keep Huntington the fantastic place it is. It's a shame people cannot discuss these issues rationally and civilly. It is my opinion that this project is needed in Huntington Station, Greenlawn, and Cold Spring Harbor to take advantage of mass transit and provide affordable housing.
Marita Eybergen June 09, 2011 at 07:12 PM
Trust me when I say they are not using the other bedrooms as office space or an extra bedroom as a guest bedroom. See that might be good for you, but not for everyone else. Unless you live in the area and I am not talking about the actual HS area I am talking about the area where no one wants to be for safety issues and fear, you will never really know what is going on, you can only assume. I live and walk the streets in my area, since I am one of the very few that is not afraid to walk this area that everyone else is afraid too, so I actually see what is going on first hand. So it is not the mentality, it is the reality.
Greg Fitzgerald June 11, 2011 at 03:24 AM
Do you see how much energy and brain power are being directed to this issue??!!? Let's get on board behind the resurgence of Huntington Station...and stop all this bickering...and actually use all this energy to make improvements. Sure, the NIMBYs can bring law suits to stop the train, but to what end??? Let's all take a deep breath and regroup toward a common goal.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »