Opinion: Limit Energy Drinks for Young

Suffolk legislator Spencer warns of stimulants' health hazards.

As an elected official and local physician, I am deeply concerned about the significant risks posed by the use of stimulant drinks by our children.  These products are often referred to as “energy drinks” but provide no energy, only stimulation.  Mounting evidence proves that there can be long-term medical harm and even sudden death in certain circumstances by ingesting these highly-caffeinated drinks.  Caffeine is not a source of energy but a stimulant.  Stimulant drinks consumed by children in middle and high school and can contain up to 800 milligrams of caffeine per serving, the equivalent of eight cups of coffee. 

In my capacity as the chairman of the Legislature’s Health Committee, I serve on the Board of Health which is charged with considering any matter pertaining to public health. The Board recently sent a letter to the Suffolk County Legislature imploring action to protect our children from the effects of caffeine toxicity and the negative effects of energy drinks.  They believe the stimulants in these drinks clearly pose a risk to our children.  In response to their concerns and the growing body of scientific evidence about the dangers of stimulant drinks, I have proposed a resolution to the NYS House of Delegates of the New York State Medical Society. This bill has the support of the Suffolk County Medical Society and recommends restricting the marketing and sale of “high-energy/stimulant drinks to children under the age of 19.”  I am hopeful that this resolution will be approved and that physicians throughout the state will support restricting these products from children.  But in the interim, I am addressing the issue locally in several ways.

First, after much research and meetings with physicians, representatives from the energy drink industry, concerned parents and school officials, I have introduced three resolutions that would affect Suffolk County residents.  The first resolution would create an educational campaign directed at junior and senior high school students to make them aware of the potentially dangerous effects of caffeine toxicity from stimulant drinks.  The next two resolutions would restrict the marketing and distribution of samples to minors in the County. 

Next, my office is working to draft a maximum caffeine cap similar to that which Health Canada is pursuing.  This would limit the concentration of caffeine in beverages sold in Suffolk County to protect against the most dangerously caffeinated products.   To be clear, this cap would not impact soft drinks or coffee but would address the most dangerous ingredient in stimulant drinks which can be exacerbated by other ingredients in some of these products.  

Finally, I realize that developing fair legislation and educating the public may not be enough to protect our children.  The Journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics published a report from the Committee on Nutrition and the Council on Sports Medicine and Fitness that recommends that school districts prohibit energy drink use and sale of caffeinated products in schools.   I have reached out to the Nassau/Suffolk School Boards Association and requested that they address this issue and encourage all Long Island school boards to regulate the sale and use of these products on school property and at school sponsored events. I have already discussed this with the six school districts in the 18th Legislative District.  I am confident they will decide to protect students in their charge. 

Our children are at risk and emergency room visits by people presenting with caffeine toxicity have increased.  It is time Suffolk County addressed this very important issue and I am working very hard to do so in a fair, informed and practical way. The energy drink lobby is a very powerful lobby and would like to conduct business unfettered by local laws.  In spite of that fact, I continue to work to fashion smart, productive and reasonable legislation to protect the lives of unsuspecting children in our County.

On March 5 at 2:30 p.m. at the General Meeting of the Legislature in Riverhead, members of the public can attend a hearing on these very important resolutions.  Please contact my office if you would like more information about this issue.

Dr. William Spencer represents the 18th District in the Suffolk County Legislature.

paul February 27, 2013 at 12:38 PM
While I believe the government does not have a role to play in the personal choices of adults. I believe it is very appropriate for regulation to be in place to protect minors. I support Dr Spencer's initiative though I believe Mayor Bloomberg has crossed the line.
Linda Otta February 27, 2013 at 04:09 PM
Dr Nanny Bloomberg Spencer just crossed the line too. oh please save me from myself! I have no self control and you are a Doctor (an ENT) so save me from the evils of caffeine. Really? A max cap on caffeine. Why not tax it? Scared of a revolution?
Mel March 02, 2013 at 03:19 PM
This is a very responsible effort. I think South Huntington already has banned their athletes from using energy drinks. They are dangerous and we shouldn't let any company or business owner give these to kids who don't understand the danger. If we don't allow cigarettes to be sold to kids, we shouldn't allow energy drinks---both have the ability to significantly harm children. I support this completely.
heather March 02, 2013 at 03:36 PM
Children are young, and they shouldnt need energy and they certainly dont need stimulants! I dont know who ever thought it would be a good idea for our children to be drinking these kind of drinks.....I would never allow my children to drink them and I wouldnt drink them myself. I would definitely support something like this.
Glenn March 20, 2013 at 07:23 PM
I agree Heather, this is common sense and you didn't need a law to tell you that. Suffolk is broke, the state is broke, and every time they pass another nanny law it cost a small fortune. Stop already, I know the good doctor thinks we elelcted him our phiysician, but thanks I'll take it from here.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »