.
Feedback

The Way We Work: Jobs That Are Gone

For Labor Day, Patch looks at how jobs have changed during the last century.

This is a story about jobs that, by and large, simply don’t exist in the United States anymore. Or if they do, are holding on by the fiber-optic thread that will soon extinguish the occupation for good.

Some are ancient history, like the iceman who has not cometh since the Eisenhower Administration. And others – including the minimum wage Wal-Mart “greeter” - were here just yesterday.

A LESS DISPOSABLE TIME

At The Sun newspaper of Baltimore – where many wonder if reporters will eventually go the way of the typewriter (and the skilled folks who repaired them) – there used to be an aged, exceedingly polite elevator operator named Barney Barney.

[Yes, his first name and his last name were – inexplicably - the same.]

Though extraordinary buildings like the Space Needle in Seattle still use an elevator operator, the job largely disappeared in the early 1950s with advancements in lift technology. But The Sun kept Barney on into the mid-1970s because he was considered part of the founding A.S. Abell company family, which owned the paper until 1986.

Corporations still say they treat employees like families, but those types of ties – like the technology that stays relevant for an entire century—is mostly a thing of the past.

Not the sweet stuff made of apples and peaches and latticed with fresh dough. The guy who runs the shoe repair shop and makes the old new again.

Cobblers have disappeared as shoes have become disposable. You can’t fix a pair of athletic shoes or anything else in which the sole and the heel is a single piece of rubber. You can wipe off a pair of gym shoes with Formula 409 – as some enterprising youngsters do on city streets for a buck – but they won’t take a shine.

As one descendent of a Hoosier cobbler said: “Most shoes just aren’t worth fixing anymore.” 

The New Orleans folksinger Trey Yip, a disciple of Ramblin’ Jack Elliott, put himself through college one summer about a decade ago by selling encyclopedias door to door in the Dakotas. The filmmaking Maysles brothers – Albert and David – made a documentary in 1969 about door-to-door Bible salesmen.

Strangers don’t sell anything door-to-door anymore. “Slumber parties” thrown by women to sell sex toys to their friends and neighbors are flourishing, but the doorbell ringing Avon Lady has gone the way of the milkman -- who now services less than half of one percent of American homes.

POST-PAPER

The most recent news of jobs lost because the world doesn’t work the way it used to do arrived just before Labor Day and concerned the products used to make encyclopedias: ink and paper.

According to Business Week, Lexmark International laid-off 1,700 workers around the globe in late August after deciding to get rid of its inkjet printer division.

The reason is the same one wreaking havoc with the United States Postal Service.

Each day, by leaps and bounds, paper is being made obsolete by increased dependence on cyberspace. From 2006 to 2009, according to reports, North American consumption of paper and cardboard declined 24 percent.

Add the paperboy to the list. As long ago as two decades ago, adults with minivans and station wagons began pushing aside the kid who threw papers on your doorstep out of a canvas satchel. As circulation and home subscriptions continue to plummet, there are fewer people of any age tossing the morning paper (evening papers are dead) into the bushes.

Already there are computer-driven algorithms spitting out “copy” that is sold by a Chicago company called Narrative Science to big-time magazines like Forbes.

THE NOISE WE LOST

And finally, a word about how work used to sound.

The American workplace once made a lot of noise. The racket – whether in the bygone shipyard or the typing pool - was constant and as comforting as the jingle bell of a cash register: It meant production.

If you lived near the broom factory, as David H. Klein did in a 1950s childhood in southwest Baltimore, the making of a wire-wound corn broom sounded something like Sly and the Family Stone.

BOOM CHAKA CHAKA! BOOM CHAKA CHAKA! BOOM CHAKA CHAKA!

It was the sound of a machine slapping wooden sticks into place before spinning wire around the broom head to fasten the straw in place. And it permeated cities like Baltimore and Cleveland and St. Louis and Milwaukee and anywhere else hardware stores sold essentials made in their own backyard.

“Everybody was working, everybody had a job” said Klein, raised by a Lithuanian grandmother who labored in a downtown clothes factory in a city that once made umbrellas, straw hats, raincoats, Chevrolets and ships. “You’d go home after work, eat, go to bed and get up and do it again.”

There are still a few American factories making brooms. The short list includes the Libman Company of Arcola, Illinois where the works are run by the great-grandchildren of founder William Libman, who started making brooms in 1896.

But none are so close to the homes of their workers that breadwinners can fall asleep to a boom-chaka-chaka lullaby that lets them know they’ll have a job in the morning.

GM September 2, 2012 at 04:44 pm
our jobs problem is not a government problem. It is a Wall Street problem. Look how well stocks are doing (Dow 13,000+), though we are in a recession. Corporations answer to the quarterly call of shareholders, which causes them to downsize when they smell a softening in revenue. This causes higher unemployment, followed by less spending, which softens revenue further, which causes more lay-offs, and so on.
This leads to the the riddle I heard from the RNC: if Bush tax cuts have been in play for 10 years or so, where's the trickle down? These cuts everybody is arguing over are in place today, yet we dove into recession. It would appear they are not helping.
John Cocchiola September 2, 2012 at 04:55 pm
First of all, we're not in a recession. A recession is three consecutive quarters of negative growth, this isn't much of a recovery, but it is not a recession, yet. Also, taking money out of the hands of people and into the hands of an incompetent, inefficient and corrupt government (both sides) isn't going to solve anything. The New Deal didn't get us out of the Depression, like Liberals love to claim, World War Two didn't get us out of the Depression, like Conservatives like to claim (all it did was solve the employment problem), what built our post war economy was a 60% cut in spending, and a 30% cut in taxes. Today, it's a world, a different global economy, and if we hammer people or those evil corporations with more taxes, they'll just leave. When they leave, it compounds our problems. We'll go and blame them, but it will be our fault.
Mary Beth September 2, 2012 at 05:09 pm
"if we hammer people or those evil corporations with more taxes, they'll just leave" Absolute nonsense. Our effective corporate tax rate 2011 was around 12%. The U.S. both taxes its corporations less and raises less in revenue from corporate taxes than its foreign competitors. And you mean to say that if we ask corporations to actually PAY the full 25% tax rate they'll flee America? Again, nonsense. What built our postwar economy was a thriving middle class created and nurtured by the New Deal. Created and nurtured by the G.I. bill.
John Cocchiola September 2, 2012 at 05:12 pm
Really Mary Beth? Why are all of the highly taxed states losing wealth? People are bugging out of New York, New Jersey and California in record numbers. Why are companies going away to do their manufacturing? We have to be competitive in a world marketplace, it ain't like the old days. Also, if you look at the numbers of the new deal, they were dismal. We were just as bad off at the beginning or World War two than when they started.
Randy Stricker September 2, 2012 at 05:15 pm
John....I didn't blame computers for the end of civilization. What I said was " this will eventually be the end of everything that was good in this country." Putting a realative few blacksmiths and tv repair men out of work hardly compares to the amount of people being affected by the use of computers to replace decent jobs. Better cars and televisions ARE a good thing to an extent. Replacing the people that make them (including outsourcing) because computers can do it is not a good thing! Sometimes evolution is a good thing....evolving into the world of "Wall-E" is not!
Wayne D. September 2, 2012 at 05:16 pm
You are right, just look at what we did to Mars many,many years ago !!!
John Cocchiola September 2, 2012 at 05:25 pm
My point is, individuals need to adapt to the changes but so does government. A Barnes and Noble can't possible last long on the Miracle Mile or the corner of Old Country Road and Glen Cove Road. The property taxes they must pay on those buildings must be through the roof. They also have payroll, insurance, payroll taxes and a huge inventory to deal with. They've adapted, their Nook e reader business is doing very well, they sold 17% of it to Microsoft for about $600,000,000, so they're set up for their changes. There should be lower property taxes on Commercial Property if they want to keep doors open, there should also be lower payroll taxes on employers if they want to keep people working. We have a long history of clobbering businesses in this country, and in this state, which is one of the reasons we're having trouble. Business is leaving the state and the country.
Randy Stricker September 2, 2012 at 05:26 pm
Mary Beth and John....I think what you are forgetting is the moral fiber and content of Americans, both private and commercial, that also refused to make a bad product! They put great pride in what they did. Today it's all about money. Not how well a product is made, but how cheaply they can make it and continue to charge higher prices for it. As far as people fleeing NY, Calif. Jersey, etc, that's exactly right! When we bought our home in East Meadow in 1995 our property taxes were...and I'll never forget it, $3487.00....today just 17 short years later they just broke $10,000.00! It still takes us almost 2 months to get a street light bulb replaced and we are still hitting the very same potholes that were here 2 years ago! AND, the New Deal did not work!
Randy Stricker September 2, 2012 at 05:27 pm
and you believe our foreign competitors country's are in better shape than we are?
Randy Stricker September 2, 2012 at 05:35 pm
Geez....that would mean everyone has to go back to the city!
Randy Stricker September 2, 2012 at 05:42 pm
Well....not for nothin', but I worked for the Home Depot for almost 14 years. I found that in the beginning many of those hardware store owners were more than happy to get away from their stores. They told me they no longer have to work straight thru nights and weekends doing their inventory, work 12 hour days, etc and basically made the same money coming to us as a professional as well as benefits they didn't have before. They told us that for the first time in their many years they could work their 8 and go home. Doesn't mean every one of them, but many! They also said that more of the customers seemed to be upset by the loss of the small stores than the owners were!
John Cocchiola September 2, 2012 at 05:45 pm
It's not about foreign competitors, it's about us. We're moving. We're moving things overseas because we're destroying opportunities here. If you were a tooth brush manufacturer, and your property taxes on your factory in NY were two million a year, and you could get the same size place in South Carolina for $100,000, or in Singapore for almost nothing, would you consider cutting your expenses and moving? If not, you wouldn't be in business long, because that's what your competitors would be doing, and the overhead on their products would be a lot less. BMW, Michelin and other corporations are setting up shop in South Carolina. Why not NY? Why not New Jersey? Why not California? Why not Michigan? Because it costs too much there. Our state is shrinking, we had 49 congressmen at one time, based on relative population. Next year we'll have 27. New Jersey lost something like 70 billion in wealth, the people with money found somewhere else to live. That's what happens.
Had Enuf! September 2, 2012 at 06:01 pm
According to President Obama, ATM machines have displaced the bank teller!
bob young September 2, 2012 at 06:26 pm
you must live in washington DC. the fed govt is sucking the life out of America and creating beuracracies that steal and launder the money of the taxpayer. dabama must go
Jason September 2, 2012 at 08:45 pm
Best buy soon to be replaced by EBAY :|
Good Girl September 2, 2012 at 10:30 pm
Probably the biggest contributing factor of all that has not been said. The growth of worldwide population has and continues to grow exponentially. Seriously testing all necessary resources. Realistically the world as we know it HAS to have some thinning of the herd in order to see real change. Sad but true. If WW1 and WW2 never occurred think what our population would be by now. (Plus all the others in the last 100 years). Change will come in some form of disaster. Its really the only way things will get better for mankind and the planet longterm. Just saying.....
Janet September 3, 2012 at 12:46 am
You are wrong Karl Marx Jr. The problem is that democrats and their supporters such as the Teacher's unions and Hospital unions are spending the money faster than it can be saved to pay the deficits. Some republicans are also complicit because the weaklings are afraid to say no.Government takes money from taxpayers and redistributes it to its welfare patrons. Look whats happening at the NY State level with these Assembymen and Senators getting indicted for kickbacks from "community organizations"
Joe September 3, 2012 at 01:35 am
There was a time in America when you took a ride in your car or on foot looking for a good paying job and you would most likely find one in a day or so. No resume, no education, no experience needed. My dad raised a family, bought his first house building crates. That's right crates. He had benefits, retirement and was a a union worker. Today you need a resume, education and in most cases someone's help just to get a job shoveling you know what. America is no longer the what it use to be unless you are educated or skilled and even then you have issues. Our problems are simple. An out of touch government, clueless consumer and a communist country that has us right where they want us. We are in self destruct mode and unless we wake up soon leaving will be the only answer left.
Jacksonian Democrat September 3, 2012 at 02:09 am
Joe,
"Communist" country? You have no idea what that means, it just sounds good for you to say it. Concentration of wealth in the hands of a small group of elite is known as an oligarchy, which is slightly left of pure dictatorship fascism. As we have somewhat independent courts and the ability to criticize power without governmental reprisal, we have not arrived at that stage yet. Communism is when the state controls everything. Last I checked, the vast majority of institutions have been privatized, from buses to sanitation. We've never had government airlines or autos (yes you will moan about a 16 month loan that was paid back with profit to the taxpayer.) Schools are being privatized daily. We are the furthest thing from communism. But you heard it on Rush or Fox so it must be true.
John Cocchiola September 3, 2012 at 02:17 am
I don't mean to speak for Joe, but I got the sense the communist county he was talking about was China. Of course, they aren't all that communist these days either, are they?
Home Town Native September 3, 2012 at 04:18 am
I've spent time in China the last few years, and it is divided into two systems. Cities and industrial areas run under a State Capitalism model (More precisely, a Socialist system much like the Fascists used in Italy and Germany in the 1920s & 30s) - Farms are still collectives or state run enterprises run by international farming conglomerates that use slave labor to do the work.
The Chinese government allows business owners to keep profits as long as they do what the government wants and do not rock the boat politcally. Get out of line, and you spend 10 years in the Prison Camps with the signature of a police officer. (Forget Trials or civil rights) America is moving closer to that form of totalitarism every day under Obama (And Bush before him), but Obama has exploited the Economic Crisis to put the shift to a centrally controlled economy in overdrive. Obama's economic advisors and allies have openly stated they think the Chinese model is what we should strive for: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204630904577056490023451980.html http://articles.businessinsider.com/2011-03-09/wall_street/30038368_1_chinese-police-china-s-foreign-ministry-chinese-authorities http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/03/09/soros-the-world-does-need-order/ The morons who worship this socialist in the White House are what Joseph Stalin used to call "useful idiots" - they are like Shepherds leading the sheep to the slaughter!
Randy Stricker September 3, 2012 at 12:50 pm
It's very difficult to find a way to phrase the words to convey your comment. Basically what you're saying is what my grandfather used to say..."every so often this country needs a war"! I agree that nature will take matters into its own hands to "balance" the earth. I lost so many friends in wars as well as a few family members and it is terrible....but it's also become a normal way of life for this planet. We are making great strides in medicine these past 100 years, but as people live well into their 80's today instead of their 60's and 70's the way they did when I was growing up, who will take care of them, and at what cost? Take away cigarettes, sugar, cafine, saturated fats, etc, and replace it with nursing homes, long term home care, medications that the pharmacutical companies charge a literal arm and a leg for and we have a huge population. Sounds terrible....I know. When I was a child there were 140 million people in this country....now in 50 short years it has easily more than doubled! What is to come in the next 50 when my grandchildren are my age and who will be here to care for them?
Randy Stricker September 3, 2012 at 12:56 pm
Exactly John...he obviously meant China....But every democrat lately is jumping on every word!
Algebra September 3, 2012 at 01:03 pm
"retracting there heads" should be their. Just sayin'
Papa Tom September 4, 2012 at 12:09 am
I started my career as a studio drummer right out of high school and made a great living for a few years playing on radio and TV commercial "jingles." Some of these jobs took no more than ten minutes and paid hundreds or thousands of dollars in residuals for years afterward.
Within a few short years, however, the recording industry changed forever with the invention of computerized drumming machines that played more precisely than any human, could be much more easily synced to video, and never got paid for studio time, expenses, union dues, or residuals. That exciting, profitable phase of my career ended for me by the time I was 22 and, although I found other ways to make a living as a freelance musician, I never lived as "high" as I had from 1980 to about 1984. Eventually, ALL instrumentation on any studio recording could be generated by computer and thousands of very talented people who had spent lifetimes honing their skills were reduced to very non-prestigious roles as catering hall musicians. Today, even those jobs have been replaced, in large part, by DJ's. So much of our lives carry a soundtrack comprising all the great music that songwriters were able to create because they could support themselves as musicians. Without the means to survive, the composers of the next generation's "classics" may never even make it into the recording studio.
GM September 4, 2012 at 01:35 am
Home Town- wow! some real dumb stuff right there.
Phil Konigsberg September 4, 2012 at 02:21 am
Finally, after about 40 posts that went off on a political or economy tangent, we have come back with a comment that was on the subject matter: A story about jobs that, by and large, simply don’t exist in the United States anymore.
My recollections of jobs that I remember but don't think exist any more: the milkman who used to deliver glass milk bottles to a milkbox kept outside our garden apartment; the fruitman who used to come to the neighborhood with his truck on a weekly basis and sell fruits (and vegetables?); and, the knife sharpener (also scissors) driving his distinctive vehicle through the neighborhood on a fairly regular basis.
Carol September 4, 2012 at 11:02 am
Thank you Phil. I wondered when/if we were ever going to get back to the topic at hand and stop with the political diatribes.
When we first moved here, we had Krug's and Dugan's, selling bread, cookies, cakes. And there also was Charles Chips...believe it or not, selling potato chips! Soda delivery trucks as well. Funny, we still have the "ice cream man" trolling the neighborhood despite our being able to buy ice cream by the 1/2 gallon (well, it used to be a 1/2 gallon) at the supermarkets at about a tenth of the price!
Amy Waldhauer September 4, 2012 at 01:20 pm
"Farm stands have been replaced by Super Stop & Shop."
Have you been down Elwood Road? Carlson's and DeLea are two farm stands, and there are other ones around. And that's here, with all the farmland having been sold to housing developers. Upstate, wher4 there are actual farms, there are loads of farm stands. People go to Super Stop and Shop because it's more convenient to make one stop for everything than to make the effort to get good produce.
John Cocchiola September 4, 2012 at 03:20 pm
Do we need to be that literal? He didn't say "All farm stands have been replaced...". There's no denying that Supermarket shopping has pushed out a lot of small businesspeople, farm stands, produce stores, milk delivery men, etc. In one neighborhood in Glen Cove, on one residential street in the "orchard" section, when I was a kid there was a butcher shop, a candy/ice cream store, a restaurant, two small grocery stores. People didn't need to drive, everything was a very short walk away. The candy store closed, the two grocery stores closed (one became apartments, the other was torn down and became parking for a car dealership), the laundry closed (and became apartments), the butcher shop closed (but became a laundromat). In some ways though, the stands are actually a good alternative to brick and mortar stores. In a lot of areas, stands aren't allowed or the fees are very hight, they can sell cheaper because they don't have the overhead. There's usually some drama when someone sets up a fruit stand near a Supermarket, or a flower stand near a florist. They don't have to worry about high rents, payroll, taxes, insurance, etc., so are able to sell for a lot less. Even with (sometimes) lower prices, most people are too busy to shop in eight different locations when they could stop at King Cullen.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Huntington Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Hillary Hess June 14, 2013 at 10:02 am
Usually cats stay within a few houses of home Sometimes they just hunker down under a neighbor'sRead More shed or deck. He is more likely to come to you at night when there aren't as many lawn mower sounds. Walk around with a can of the stinkiest cat food that you can find. Call to him, and listen for a response. He may answer you with soft meows. Make a trail of stinky cat food to your door and leave the can at the door overnight. Hang up signs with a photo in the neighborhood. Go door to door and tell neighbors to call you if they see him. Kids playing, and dog walkers might spot him. Once you have an idea, of where he is, you can use a have a heart trap to catch him, if he won't come to you. Some cats get so scared when they get out, that they don't recognize their humans. We have had cats disappear for months, before trapping them.
marie.white92 June 13, 2013 at 04:08 pm
Tuesday about 7am at the intersection of Jericho and 110-I think it was 3 cars with an overturnedRead More silver SUV. Saw it right after it happened-about 7 people were trying to push the SUV upright
Pam Robinson (Editor) June 13, 2013 at 05:13 pm
We've checked with authorities on this and they say there were no major injuries. While we try toRead More get to every serious accident, we're not going to be able to cover everything that happens 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
marie.white92 June 14, 2013 at 09:45 pm
Well it looked bad-glad that the drivers are ok.