patching...
Update: Got a new smartphone? Get the Patch App! http://huntington.patch.com/mobile
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Second State Senate District Candidates Debate

Incumbent John J. Flanagan and challenger Ira Bernstein answer questions at League of Women Voters Debate.

 

A packed room came to hear state Sen. John J. Flanagan, R-East Northport, and opponent Ira Bernstein at Thursday night's League of Women Voters Debate at Harborfields Public Library in Greenlawn.

With the Nov. 2 election just days away, candidates from several races took turns answering questions on central issues, from jobs to taxes.

Bernstein, a Democrat and former Commack Union Free School District teacher, focused on an issue close to his heart. He said education is important on Long Island, with over 66 percent of taxes from the region going towards schools.

"Teachers must evaluate performance and keep education current," Bernstein said, citing that students relying on Sallie Mae loans to fund their education may be contributing to the next banking crisis.

Flanagan, an East Northport resident and four-term state Senator beginning with his election in 2002, said that the concentration of votes in the state Assembly for New York City is a detriment to the Long Island system, and ultimately the state SUNY system.

"Property taxes have always been an issue," Flanagan said. "The state shouldn't walk away from its obligation to higher education. SUNY educations are the best buy nationwide."

Flanagan also said that public school funding should no longer be based on the enrollment numbers for a given county, but rather on the attendance figures, leaving the responsibility up to the administrators to keep the children in school.

The environment – and how to fund programs to protect it – was another issue that the community presented to the candidates

Bernstein's answer ranged from traffic jams and pollution from local chemical and manufacturing companies, citing the fact that Lake Ronkonkoma is no longer open as a swimming location in Suffolk County.

"I would go after the companies and promote organic gardens in schools to show children how to care for the environment," he said.

Flanagan said adequate funding is needed to keep the environmental protection programs running.

"We must properly fund programs,'' he said. "Past New York state budgets, which I voted against, do not help protect these laws and do not help protect the environment."

At the end of the formal question and answer session, Lisa Scott of the League of Women Voters of Smithtown and event moderator, questioned candidates on three topics in a 30-second lightning round format. The issues were Medicaid benefits and reform, affordable housing and affordable child care.

Flanagan said that New York state spends four percent, approximately $52 billion, on Medicaid benefits and funding and that if he were re-elected, he would push Albany to take a "hardcore look at what we can afford and the fraud in the system."

Bernstein said that prevention should be looked at as a serious alternative to the overuse of medication, which he said contributes to accidents on the roads and ultimately even more money spent by the government.

Flanagan left the debate before answering the final two questions in the lightning round, but Bernstein said low-income affordable housing would only work if it was approved by the community. He said multi-generational housing may also be a possibility to alleviate the problems in Suffolk County.

Look for our voter guides next week to help you understand more about the candidates, their policies and their districts.

 

Related Topics: Commack Schools, Elections, Ira Bernstein, John Flanagan, State Senate, and Voting
What's the most important issue for you this election? Tell us in the comments.

CommackMom

11:45 pm on Sunday, October 24, 2010

Bernstein is pandering for the teacher vote. He's a former Commack teacher. See what he was quoted as saying in Newsday last week:

"He said he believes teacher pensions - Bernstein is a former teacher - are often seen as bloated, when in fact, they are reasonable for a Long Island cost of living.
"Most retired teachers are not that well off," he said."

Hahahaha...Teacher salaries 'reasonable'? Retired teachers 'not that well off' ? ? By virtue of the fact they are one of a very small percentage of retirees who collect a pension, I would say they are VERY well off.

If this guy gets in, kiss your property taxes goodbye - they'll be headed for the moon. If the liberal rag Newsday isn't endorsing him, you can imagine what a mistake he is. Vote for John Flanagan.

Reply

pat Bertini

7:11 pm on Wednesday, October 27, 2010

I am a former teacher and I can tell you my pension is not as high as you think. After property taxes and bills here on LI it is certainly not enough to live on as I use to. Have to work a part time job to help out. Under Flanagan's plan there would be a constitutional convention and the pension system would be opened up which would lead to many teachers living below standard. If you are a private person who retired with a poor pension IT WAS YOUR CHOICE.I also know for a fact he was misquoted in Newsday.
Teachers have to sacrifice much of their time in dedicating

Reply

CommackMom

11:27 pm on Wednesday, October 27, 2010

I resent being shouted at 'IT WAS YOUR CHOICE'. You make it seem as if collecting a pension in retirement was a prime consideration in choosing your career. Might not you have gone into teaching if not for the perk at the end of the rainbow? Furthermore, I never said I wasn't collecting a pension - poor or otherwise. That was your assumption.
You say you 'know for a fact' Mr. Bernstein was misquoted in Newsday. How do you come to know that? And, what did he actually say? Please do enlighten us. You also state Flanagan's plan 'would lead to many teachers living below standard'. Will it only affect teachers?
I agree property taxes on LI are out of control. Ever take a look at the percent paid toward school taxes.
Lastly, I feel a pension of $67,738 is pretty darn nice !

Reply

Kelly Campbell

3:46 pm on Thursday, October 28, 2010

I think people make career choices based on a wide range of factors and teachers are equally altruistic in their choise of profession as New York state senators, whomever they may be.

The base pay for a New York State Senator is almsot $79,500 per year. Members receive additional stipends for holding committee or party positions. I believe they receive a pension but could not find information one way or another as of yet.

Anyway, I did find out that Senator Flanagan joined Attorney General Andrew M. Cuomo in Oct. 2009 in announcing new, bipartisan legislation that would replace the sole trustee at the New York State Common Retirement Fund with a board of trustees instead of it being managed by a sole trustee, the state comptroller, currently Tom DiNapoli, a Democrat.

The Common Retirement Fund, last valued at $116.5 billion, is the state’s largest pool of money, according to nysenate.gov. And that is not all in the Teachers' Retirement System account.

Reply

Leave a comment