Looks like the vote is well divided. Some tough choices here for sure.

If you do not include Lisa's Buffalo Grille in Greenlawn, you are missing out! The best wings around!

Best wings in Huntington without a doubt are Shamrock Gold from The Shamrock

Nicky's wing were fed steroids, ther is lots of meat and spice to boot. Never had wings in some of these other establishments but when I am away the wings are usually not up to my standards.

Maria's def the best. But this list is horrible. Taxi's has been closed for a year, and the fact that KFC, outback and Friday's are on the list just proves that this list holds no weight. Golden Coach Diner is gross, and shamrock wings are undercooked 90% of the time.

By far Rookies has the best wings and 2 great wing nights... I love there food.

ROOKIES!!!! An awesome wing and a deafening experience!!! THE BEST IN HTOWN!

Rookies has the best wings. Hands down.

Sapsuckers has "the best" wings!!! Buffalo glaze and house gorgonzola sauce.

Have to say The Shamrock has the best wings in town and by far the largest variety of sauces.There is no competion!!!

Finley's has the best wings. $5 all you can eat during Football Games

Finley's best wings by far

I love to shamrock and Sonia and the wings are yummy too.

Hi joe

Maries in Huntington Station

Joe at shamrock is professional chef....

Sweet joe at shamrock has best wings in huntington!

ROOKIES BY FAR THE BEST!!! And why is KFC, outback and these other chains on the list? Come on!

Rookies is the best! Coming from someone that lives in Indiana and craves wings in New York that's a serious compliment!

Lot of Shamrock fans here. Please do review the place: http://huntington.patch.com/listings/the-shamrock

Shamrock freakin rules jason

Shamrock is hands down best food all around from burgers to wings!!

I agree with all the shamrock fans!!! Lets go Shamrock!!! Free wings on Sundays during football season! if you ask Joe to grill them for you, try them like, there freaking awesome!!

I haven't tried all these places for wings, but Shamrock has great wings and I'm with Greg that Lisa's Buffalo Grill does a great job and should have been included!

Sweet Joes Grilled Buffallo wings are insane!!!!!

Rookies is clearly the best...no competition.

Finleys=best wings by far

I have to admit it, I eat wings twice a week and free wing s are better! Kind of, I find that lots of times when they are on special they are either pre-cooked or rushed and not always cooked properly. I will always go to Shamrock or Rookies when they do an all you can eat special but when (I’m paying) I want them cooked crisp and consistent. Finley’s gets my vote for best wings worth paying for. I prefer traditional Buffalo wings with a thick sauce, real chunky blue cheese, carrots and celery, the crisper the better, Finley’s by far fits the bill no pun intended, but if I’m going to eat on the cuff, the all you can eat wings at Rookies are fine

Finleys has the best wings hands down!!!!! Football sundays are a blast and the wings are all you can eat!

Sean. Finley's has the best wings, most beer, and best service. Winner!

Finley's of Greene Street by far has the best wings in Huntington!! They are absolutely delicious. If you haven't tried them you MUST. So good.

Shamrocks wings are never pre cooked! those suckers are so big when they come out, they aint those little wings, and there always crispy and juicy! consistanly done rite!! and there bleu cheese has chunks of real cheese in it. Common already Shamrocks got them all beat!!!!

Id put The Shamrock head to head with any catagory this Patch wants the thro out there! burgers, pasta, salads ect.... against any restaurant anywhere.! there new chef whos been there acouple of years now is one the nicest guys i know out there, takes pride in his ingredients and it shows in everythings he cooks, hes always out the dining room after dish he cooks to make sure everyones happy! Hes old school but young. You just dont get that treatmeant anymore in restaurants.

I agree with John and everyone else who is voteing for the shamrock, food is unreal there, truly a underated place. Yea there wings are awesome and got my vote. there burger is one of the best i ever had too. always cooked to how i want it. the chef is awesome and his name is Joe. why does everyone call him sweet joe? he is a nice guy. ive meet him in the dinning room acouple of times, is that why?

Gotta admitt i wouldnt of stepped foot into the shamrock untill someone told me they had someone new running it, acouple of times i went into the shamrock the owner was a drunken mess. crazy crowd the situation made me feel uncomfortable. I took my friends advice and checked it out, iam now there acouple a times a week... with my kids. Foods so good, atmosphere is fun, and prices are great. I even went there for valentines day. it was better than any 5 star restaurant, seriously.. Highly recommended. O yea wings are awesome. go Shamrocks.

FINLEYS are the only wings I'll eat...deliciousness!!!!

This is a tough one!!! wings... everyone likes them diffrent, so iam judgeing on quality of wing! Shamrocks definatly has a quality wing, so does Finelys,. I like my wings crispy with just a glaze of origianal hot sauce on it. with a good chunky bleu cheese and celery. And my vote goes to The shamrock for that reason, they listen to their customers request. And i guess his name is joe from this forum does it rite everytime!! consistent, consistency wins me everytime!! good job Joe & the shamrock.. Finelys aint no push over!! but the shamrock got my vote on the wings!!!

Shamrock wings are the best and the owner is a great guy who has been in the business for over 30 years...He knows what he is doing!!!

Good point Jeremy!! I go the Shamrock for their naked wings! Salt N Pepper with all their sauces on the side! Finelys and Shamrocks should have a wings down!!

When will they announce the winner??

Shamrocks all the way! croxley ales in garden city comes close to shamrocks. they do it right there too. Had anyone ever had the shamrocks corned beef? to die for. You have to go to a jewish deli in Manhatten somewhere to get anything even close! they definalty do a good job. And i believe its a father/son operation.

FUNNY STOry i went into the shamrocks one nite and theres James caan shooting pool with the owner!! they must be doing something right. they have photos of all diffrents kinds of celeberties at the shamrock hanging up. and there not just head shots, their photos of them actually there!! celeberties only go to places where the food is awesome! so thats good for the Shamrocks. Iam not a big wing fan. but i had them there and they where good! i go there for there burgers.

Does anyone have any information on the chef at the shamrock?? cause i never went there, then all of a sudden the shamrock does a 360 and now there AWESOME! is he just the chef, or new owner or Family? he takes care of his customer like a owner would. everytime i see him i feel stupid asking. If anyone knows iam interested? is he married? hahahahah..

These posts are making me hungry.

Funny Susan I was wondering the same thing about the owner Kevin...does anyone know if he is married.I hear he cooks too,maybe we could double!!

Lets everyone keep in mind this is a best wing voting ballot! so lets keep all the negativity to ourselfs!! thanks

WAIT!! so i chef Joe marryed??? i know this is a wing competition but i gottta no!?? yes or No!!

Sweet Joe from the shamrock makes wings much better than finkeys!!!

We Love Sweet Joe the Chef!!!!

All the Hollywood Celebrities visit the Shamrock look at their wall Photos they were there!

I luv sweet joe

Sweet joe made us his seafood and spagetti holy smokes! His food is best in huntington.....

Sweet joe from shamrock will bring home the gold!

Shamrock hands down is the best ... I drive miles to get them!

Finley's are the best in town........
And they've got any beer you could want to go with them.....

If you havent tried Sweet Joes wings at Shamrock run there and try them now. They are amazing.

FINLEYS!!!! Hands down the best wings!!! Always order them well done and they always come out the way I ask. On a side note, how in the world did KFC make the list of choices???

By Far Finley's Wings are THE BEST!!!! crispy and saucy! SOOOOOOOO GOOOOOOD!!!!!

went to the shamrock today to see what all the hype was all about! and let me tell you i ordered the shamrock gold wings and they were the best i ever had crispy and glazed perfectly! i sat in there new dining room and it was a great experience!! and the chef is goodlooking, if its that guy chef joe!! hahah

Finley's has THE BEST wings, a HUGE beer selection & the friendliest staff too!!! AND it's got the biggest outdoor bar & deck in Huntington! WINNING!

I cast my vote for FINLEY'S!!!!! I love that place!!!

Finleys has my vote.....aaaaaamazing wings!

My vote is for the shamrock! always good wings,, very consistant and a variety of sauces.

MAIN STREET CAFE IN NORTHPORT THE BEST WINGS

Finley's are the best..

Shamrocks all the way! done rite everytime!!

Finleys!!! The wings are beyond good and always cooked to order! Love the football special too

extra crispy, chunky bleu cheese perfect hot sauce. even there celery and carrot combination is great on the side! The shamrocks got my vote! Steamed clams are awesome too.

Shamrocks rocks it!! Best wings! And especially when your friendly beautiful bartender Dawn delivers them to you!

Comment thread record?

Winner announced tomorrow. Thanks for the great response!

Shamrock wings rock!....plus The bartender was delicious & the wings were extremely helpful..........

Rookies is by far the best....10 great flavors and consistently delicious. My favorite!

What to shamrock again tonight. Sweet joe your wings are amazing!

Love the feedback about Finley's. If you are a fan, please leave a review: http://huntington.patch.com/listings/finleys-of-greene-street

We have a winner! Watch video of The Shamrock's wing technique http://patch.com/A-rnlH